Skip to main content
Bars

Beer Church Brewing Co.

Bar in New Buffalo

[We trained in the Neapolitan pizza style under the grand masters of Napoletana, Pizzaiolo Roberto Caporuscio and Pizzaiola Giorgia Caporuscio of Kesté NYC, and are thrilled to have brought that art form to Southwest Michigan. The dough is always made fresh and fermented according to the secrets of old Napoli, and you can watch our Pizzaioli ply their unique trade in our two open pizza kitchens, one inside and one out, where they stretch and build your pie using only the finest ingredients. Scroll down for a look at our Menu, which also includes wings, sandwiches, salads, and small plates.

OUR BEER GARDEN

All have been hailing our Beer Church Garden from the moment it first opened in 2018 to great fanfare, with some calling it the Wrigley Field of Brewery Beer Gardens, others the “Single Greatest Beer Garden” mankind has ever contemplated over a beer in the Midwest, to but paraphrase the hoopla. We’ve pushed the superlatives even further with our 2022 additions of a 21+ UPPERDECK featuring giant TVs and Michigan’s largest outdoor bar; a family-friendly covered patio with gas heaters overhead and primary-colored couches underneath; and a second Acunto oven from Napoli anchoring our new outdoor pizza kitchen butressed by a Mondrian-inspired counter. As always, all of these spaces are full service just like our icy air-conditioned indoor environs, which is pretty damn cool aesthetically in its own right!

OUR HISTORY

A Civil War era iconic church at the crossroads of downtown New Buffalo, Michigan, A brief role as an improvised armory during a time of need. What better bones upon which to build a brewery? We saved it from knockdown and buildup of who-knows-what franchise because it’s a beautiful place for you to have a beautiful beer – and true Pizza Napoletana!

Similar Recommendations

Illegal Pete’s Tejon

Illegal Pete’s Tejon

This unique restaraunt allows you to build your own bowls/burritos and then you can sit at a bar to eat it if you want. Great atmosphere!

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

My wife and I had a great experience at this location today . We were told it was a 45 min wait but got seated in 15 minutes which was awesome. Food was hot and fresh, the appetizers were great and came out fast . Our server Becca was awesome she provided excellent service. Will definitely return to this location

3rd Base Bar & Grill

3rd Base Bar & Grill

Made a quick stop here for some food and a beer after a long drive from Oregon to Maine. The atmosphere although a little loud (but it’s a bar scene so who cares) was great. The waitress did an amazing job despite how busy it was. She was fast and catered to my gals and my needs. Over all my gal and I loved the visit to the bar and grill. Andi haven’t even gotten to the food yet. We ordered a jumbo clam basket and chilli as an appetizer. The chilli tasted like your run of the mill chilli the clams were good. But my gal ordered pineapple habanero wingless chicken wings which were to die for. I ordered a burger and fries. The fries were fresh looked like they were made right from the potato. The fries alone were amazing. But this burger. My first bite, I felt like I died and went to heaven. Real (not literally) out of body experience. This burger has ruined my expectations of what any other burger should taste like. I can’t even describe it. It was perfectly cooked, the flavor was amazing it was huge. Mind you I ordered the biggest burger. I’m a bartender myself and hands down this was one of my Greatest experiences on my 3000 mile trip. I’ll be returning here in my way back to Oregon.

Bars
Website
Casey’s New Buffalo

Casey’s New Buffalo

Great spot for grabbing food or watching a game (if at or near the bar). We stopped by for drinks and apps and it is much easier to get food here over other places. The apps where great. We had the calamari, chips & dip, and truffle fries… not foods that are easy to mess up, but I did see lots of options on their menu that was rather impressive for ‘bar food’. Lots of fish options I would try and the salad section looks fresh and delightful! Have been here more than once and would come back again. I haven’t seen the outdoor space but it looks nice in the photos!